Jim Lydotes explores a changing market backdrop, the next test for utilities, and the one-time boost hiding behind some standout consumer earnings.
Transcript
Just like that, the defensive re-rating is behind us.
We’re past the midterms and thinking about policy changes, and the early read is still pretty positive for power.
And some of this quarter's best margins came with a refund check attached.
I'm Jim Lydotes and these are our three points in three minutes.
So let's flip over the timer and let's go.
First up, a status update on the defensive rebound. A few months back, we flagged defensives as really unloved, cheap part of the market, especially health care and utilities. Both were trading at meaningful discounts to the S&P 500 on a forward earnings multiple.
So where are we now?
Health care has really been the standout. The XLV, which is a health care ETF, is up more than 30% over the last six months. and it's gone from about an 18% discount to the overall market to a 9% premium to the market. So that trade, I'd say, has largely played out.
Consumer staples, not to the extent that we saw in health care, but we've certainly seen a sharp re-rating higher here over the last couple of months. Utilities have been the laggard. They're basically flat. I'd say still the one defensive pocket that remains trading at a discount to the overall equity market. so health care has had a move, but I think the easy money's probably behind us. Staples similarly has had a move and as a group probably looks a little bit less appealing than it was, but utilities have not yet played out, and the fundamentals here may be getting a little bit better.
Second, some takeaways from EEI, which is the utility industry's big annual conference, which just wrapped up, and our analysts have been working through some of the most important takeaways there. I'd say the short version here is the data center story is still intact, but the market is about to pay for execution and not just ambition.
First, bankable loads beat headline pipeline. So hyperscalers are not backing away. The bottlenecks for data centers still remain transmission, generation, permitting, and financing. And the winners in this space are going to be the utilities that can connect the load and fund the build, and not the ones with the largest pipelines.
Second, affordability is the number one political issue. The winners will be the utilities that can really prove that data centers are going to be able to keep bills stable for everybody else. And finally, the blue wave looks pretty manageable. Managements were were far calmer than the market was anticipating. Their message was this is largely an evolution. It's not really a revolution. And so despite the political noise, the long-term power contracts are still getting signed. Finally, read the fine print on margins.
Some of this earnings season's strongest profit margins, especially from consumer companies, are coming in right now, and they aren't necessarily what they may seem. When the courts struck down a big set of import tariffs, companies that had already paid them started getting refunds, and there was a lot of money that landed in third quarter results all at once. This is really focused on areas like apparel brands, retailers. Even automakers reported margin jumps. And in many cases, the refund did much of the work in the quarter. In one case, it added almost six points to gross margins. And in others, if you take out the refund, the margins were flat or even falling.
So these are one-time windfalls. I'd say the real test comes in 2027 when the refunds are gone and costs are still high. When a company touts record margins, you gotta ask yourself how much came from the underlying health of the business and how much came from the refund. It's something you really gotta watch, especially around the consumer space.
So that's our three points in three minutes with a little sand left in the bottle.
Have a great week and we'll see you back here next time.
Risks: Principal risks are generally those attributable to investing in stocks and related derivative instruments. Holdings are subject to market, issuer and other risks, and their values may fluctuate. Market risk is the risk that securities or other instruments may decline in value due to factors affecting the securities markets or particular industries. Issuer risk is the risk that the value of a security or instrument may decline for reasons specific to the issuer, such as changes in its financial condition.
